In a gripping case involving Lowe’s Companies, Inc., a shopper named Rene Moreno suffered injuries when a sink fell from a shelf, dislodged by a store employee. As the Morenos pursued justice, they sought access to Lowe’s internal database tracking accident claims, only to face resistance from the company, which claimed trade secret protection. The ensuing legal battle raised critical questions about the balance between a plaintiff’s right to information and a defendant’s claim of confidentiality. Discover how the Court of Appeals navigated this complex issue and what it means for future litigation.